Some of the most important strategic conversations begin with a sentence everyone in the boardroom has heard: "We can't afford it."

Sometimes that statement is accurate. Sometimes it reflects an understandable concern about protecting members' money. And sometimes it ends a conversation before anyone has actually done the math.

For small credit unions, that last possibility deserves attention. An investment we reject today may be something our next generation of members already expects. Repeatedly postponing those investments can leave us financially comfortable on paper while becoming less relevant in members' daily lives.

That is where mission and vision need to enter the conversation.

Longtime board members often love their credit union deeply. They remember the people it helped, the circumstances that brought it into existence, and the personal relationships that made it special. That loyalty is valuable. Many small credit unions would not exist without it.

But affection for the credit union we joined thirty years ago can influence what we believe the credit union should look like today. Familiar practices become part of its identity. Change begins to feel like a threat to something worth protecting.

Our responsibility is to carry the mission forward. That requires understanding how members' lives have changed and being willing to change how we serve them.

A Fifty Thousand Dollar Decision

During a recent strategic planning session I facilitated, a small credit union had a capital ratio of approximately 15%. Our member research revealed that younger members were only lightly engaged. They belonged to the credit union, but much of their financial business was happening elsewhere.

Apple Pay was one of the more common requests. Its absence was also among the reasons younger members gave for not having a checking account there.

The estimated implementation cost was $50,000.

The board's response was, "We can't afford it."

I understand that reaction. Fifty thousand dollars is a substantial amount of money to most people. Volunteer directors bring their personal experience with money into the boardroom, just as the rest of us do.

But a household budget and a credit union balance sheet operate at different scales. The size of a number can create an emotional response that is very different from its financial impact.

The size of a number can create an emotional response that is very different from its financial impact.

When we examined this credit union's capital position, the distance between the perceived risk and its actual financial capacity became clear. The conversation needed to move from how expensive $50,000 felt to what spending $50,000 would actually do.

The member research did not guarantee that Apple Pay would create primary checking relationships. It did, however, identify a specific barrier. That deserved a business case and a financial model.

Capital Does Not Automatically Preserve Independence

Merger data makes this conversation especially relevant.

CEO Advisory Group's analysis of 35 NCUA merger approvals in the first quarter of 2025 reported a median net worth ratio of 11.92% among the merging credit unions. Almost 75% cited expanded services as their primary merger reason, while approximately 8% cited poor financial condition. Yet 17 of the 35 institutions, 49%, had negative ROA over the preceding 12 months. These figures describe that quarter's approvals, rather than every credit union merger.

The pattern is instructive. Credit unions can enter a merger with substantial accumulated capital while facing challenges with earnings, services, or long-term viability.

NCUA's published merger guidance offers similar context. Its table covering 2017 to 2021 identifies expanded services as the primary reason for approximately 76% of mergers. The guidance recommends periodically polling members about needed services, identifying technology changes, and exploring partnerships to provide additional capabilities.

These findings do not establish that every well-capitalized credit union could have avoided merging by investing in technology. Expanded services also encompasses much more than technology. They do challenge the assumption that consolidation is always the consequence of having too little capital.

Accumulated capital gives a credit union a cushion. Sustainable earnings and meaningful member relationships help give it a future. Boards need to consider all three.


Put the Investment in Proportion

Consider an illustrative credit union with $100 million in assets and $15 million in net worth, a 15% net worth ratio.

If a $50,000 implementation cost were paid in cash and fully expensed immediately, with no offsetting income, net worth would fall to $14.95 million and assets to $99.95 million. The resulting ratio would be approximately 14.96%.

That is a decline of about 0.04 percentage points.

For earnings, assume the same institution has $100 million in average assets and expects annual net income of $500,000, producing a 0.50% ROA. Expensing the $50,000 would reduce annual net income to $450,000 and ROA to 0.45%, holding average assets constant.

That is a meaningful expense, 10% of the projected annual earnings in this example. It is also a very different proposition from an investment that threatens the institution's capital position.

For perspective, an immediate $3 million cash expense with no return would leave this illustrative institution with $12 million in net worth and $97 million in assets, or approximately 12.37% capital. That extreme scenario illustrates scale. It is no recommendation to absorb unnecessary losses.

NCUA's net worth threshold for the well-capitalized classification is 7%, and complex credit unions face additional capital tests. Seven percent is a regulatory classification threshold, rather than an appropriate operating target for every institution. Boards must maintain a cushion suited to their risks, growth plans, and supervisory circumstances.

Capital also is not a separate checking account available for spending. Liquidity, recurring expenses, and the ability to replenish capital through earnings matter. Management should model the actual accounting treatment and asset denominator used by its credit union.

Still, those considerations should improve the analysis. They should not replace it with an automatic "no."

Connect the Numbers to the Mission

Affordability is only part of the decision. An affordable investment can still be a poor investment.

In this case, the strategic issue was younger members' limited engagement. Apple Pay mattered because members identified its absence as a barrier to using the credit union for everyday banking. The business case should therefore connect implementation to a broader effort to earn their checking relationships.

That means budgeting for ongoing costs, preparing staff, encouraging adoption, and measuring whether members actually become more engaged. Relevant measures could include active checking accounts among younger members, direct deposit adoption, debit usage, and retention. Downloads or enrollments alone would provide an incomplete picture.

The board should also evaluate the consequences of postponing the investment. Continuing to lose everyday transactions to other institutions may carry costs that never appear as a single line in the budget.

Mission explains whom we exist to help and why. Vision describes the institution we need to become to keep helping them. Together, they should guide how we use financial strength.

Protecting the credit union's future may require accepting a manageable reduction in near-term earnings to remove a documented barrier to membership engagement.

The analysis should establish whether that tradeoff makes sense.


This Month's Boardroom Question

What is one investment that would advance our mission and vision that we have said "we can't afford," and what happens to our ROA and capital when we actually model its full cost?

Before the next board meeting, ask the CEO to bring one previously deferred investment and a short analysis using the credit union's current capital position and annualized ROA. Include implementation and recurring costs, realistic benefits, and a downside scenario in which adoption is slower and revenue does not improve. Show the impact over the next 12 months and the following two years, including liquidity and the board's own capital target.

At the meeting, agree on a concrete disposition: approve the investment with an owner and measures of success, establish a feasible path with a budget and decision date, or decline it for a documented financial or strategic reason.

A board may reach the same decision after doing that work. But it will have reached it through evidence and stewardship.

The members who built our credit union deserve to see their legacy continue. The members who will sustain it need a credit union that fits their lives. Doing the math is one way we honor both.

About the Author
Bo McDonald, Founder and President of So Much Good. Email bo@somuchgood.com, phone 864-230-1923, somuchgood.com